It’s a longstanding tradition in the newspaper business that when anyone leaves a paper, their colleagues prepare a mock front page to mark their departure. It is further tradition that the faux front be caustic, sarcastic, borderline libelous and R-rated. I’ve had three of them done for me, and I tend to keep them out of sight of decent people. But I treasure them.
It’s a measure of the state of the industry that many departing journalists don’t get such individual send-offs nowadays, simply because there’s no time to prepare them all. When 31 reporters and editors left the News & Observer Tuesday, after having had their jobs eliminated in the latest round of cuts, one fake front page had to suffice for all of them. And rather than focusing its sarcasm on the departed, the front page took square aim at McClatchy Newspapers, owner of the N&O, and its CEO, Gary Pruitt — who are portrayed as the Titanic and its captain, respectively. (You can see the page at this link. Click on the words “mock page one.”)
What you’ll also see there is a comment from former top McClatchy editor, Howard Weaver, who scolds the N&Oers for the “thoughtless and unfounded recrimination” he senses in that fake front page. On his blog, Weaver has more to say on the subject:
” … those who argue that McClatchy took over a thriving N&O and greedily ran it into the ground are misinformed, and perpetuating that myth hurts the cause of reconstruction.”
That’s right: On the occasion of the end of their careers, Weaver is chiding the journalists for letting off some sarcastic steam. Good God, how dense and self-involved can one human be? These people have just lost their freakin’ jobs, and Weaver’s response is to demand they stop “perpetuating the myth” that McClatchy has anything to do with it.
Really, it’s breathtaking. Weaver spins the corporate line with a vigor and shamelessness that would embarrass even the most jaded public relations hack. For all his talk about “facts,” Weaver can’t seem to acknowledge one simple, obvious one: The News & Observer has diminished dramatically under McClatchy’s ownership, and only part of that decline is attributable to a poor economy.
Furthermore, that fact is confirmed by an unimpeachable source — the guy who sold the N&O to McClatchy.
Howard, on behalf of those at the N&O who are too polite or too restrained to speak plainly, let me offer this thought, delivered to you with journalistic concision and no ambiguity: Bugger off.